Везде
Language as a Dynamic System: the Legacy of W. von Humboldt and Сontemporary Linguistics
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
Language as a Dynamic System: the Legacy of W. von Humboldt and Сontemporary Linguistics
Annotation
PII
S1811-833X0000616-7-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Petr Kusliy  Ekaterina Vostrikova
Edition
Volume 57 Issue 1
Pages
110-130
Abstract
In this article, we examine the key ideas of Wilhelm von Humboldt about language and their relevance to the contemporary research in the field of linguistics. In his works, N.Chomsky describes Humboldt as a key predecessor of the generative approach. The authors discuss the concrete aspects of Humboldt’s influence on generative linguistics drawing special attention to his notion of Form. The authors also observe that Humboldt’s works also contain statements about the deep differences that exist between different languages, as well as statements that different languages ​​can form different pictures of the world. These ideas resonate with philosophical ideas about linguistic relativity (the famous Sapir-Whorf hypothesis), which are incompatible with generative linguistics. The authors try to reconcile an apparent contradiction by appealing to two different perspectives on language that they call the dynamic and the static one. They provide arguments in favor of the former and explore existing arguments against the later, which is associated with the aforementioned hypothesis. The authors conclude by pointing out that Humboldt’s legacy has so many facets that it introduces to incompatible views on language each of which had a serious impact on the studies of language in the 20th century.
Keywords
Humboldt, Chomsky, Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, linguistics, Form, grammar, syntax, semantics
Date of publication
01.03.2020
Number of purchasers
22
Views
567
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

    

  1. Berwick, R.C. & N. Chomsky. Why Only Us. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2016. 224 pp.
    2. 

  2. Bolhuis, J., I. Tattersall, N. Chomsky & R.C. Berwick. 2014. “How Could Language Have Evolved?”, PLoS Biology. 12: e1001934. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001934
    3. 

  3. Boroday, S.Yu. “Yazyk i poznanie: postrelyativistskaya issledovatel'skaya programma” [Language and Cognition: A Postrelativist Research Program], Voprosy Jazykoznanija, 2019, vol. 4, pp. 106‒136. (In Russian)
    4. 

  4. Boroday, S.Yu. “Sovremennoe ponimanie problemy lingvisticheskoi otnositel'nosti: raboty po prostranstvennoi kontseptualizatsii” [The Contemporary Interpretation of the Problem of Linguistic Relativity: Works on Space Conceptualization], Voprosy jazykoznanija, 2013, no. 4, pp. 17‒54. (In Russian)
    5. 

  5. Boroditsky, L., Schmidt, L. A., & Phillips, W. “Sex, Syntax, and Semantics”, in: D. Gentner & S. Goldin-Meadow (eds.). Language in Mind: Advances in the Study of Language and Thought. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2003, pp. 61‒79.
    6. 

  6. Chomsky, N. Kartezianskaya lingvistika. Glava iz istorii ratsionalisticheskoĭ mysli [Cartesian Linguistics. A chapter in the Histroy of Rationalist Thought]. Moscow: KomKniga 2005, 232 pp. (In Russian)
    7. 

  7. Chomsky, N. Current Issues in Linguistic Theory. The Hague: Mouton, 1964, 119 pp.
    8. 

  8. Chomsky, N., A.J. Gallego, D. Ott. “Generative Grammar and the Faculty of Language: Insights, Questions, and Challenges”, Catalan Journal of Linguistics Special Issue, 2019, pp. 229‒261.
    9. 

  9. Crain, S. & R. Thornton. Investigations in Universal Grammar. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1998.
    10. 

  10. Crain, S. & S. Thornton. “Syntax Acquisition”, WIREs Cognitive Science, 2012, vol. 3, pp. 185‒203.
    11. 

  11. Crain, S., L. Koring, and R. Thornton. “Language Acquisition from a Biolinguistic Perspective”, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 2017, vol. 81(B), pp. 120‒149.
    12. 

  12. Descartes, R. Izbrannye proizvedeniya [Selected works]. Мoscow: Gospolitizdat, 1950, 712 pp.
    13. 

  13. Devitt M., Sterelny, K. Language and Reality. 2nd Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999.
    14. 

  14. Dzhohadze, I.D. “V zashchitu semanticheskogo eksternalizma. Argumenty khilari patnema” [In Defense of the Semantic Externalism. Hilary Putnam’s Arguments], the philosophy journal, 2017, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 154‒162. (In Russian)
    15. 

  15. Elbourne, P. Meaning: A Slim Guide to Semantics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.
    16. 

  16. Everett D.L. Don’t sleep, there are snakes: Life and language in the Amazonian jungle. New York: Pantheon Books, 2008.
    17. 

  17. Feldman, H., S. Goldin-Meadow & L. Gleitman. “Beyond Herodotus: The Creation of Language by Linguistically Deprived Deaf Children”, in A. Lock (ed.). Action, Gesture, and Symbol. London: Academic Press, 1978, pp. 349-414.
    18. 

  18. Gajewski, J. On Analyticity in Natural Language. Cambridge, MA: MIT, 2000.
    19. 

  19. Gordon, P. “Numerical Cognition Without Words: Evidence from Amazonia”, Science, 2004, no. 306, pp. 496‒99.
    20. 

  20. Humboldt, V. von. “O razlichii stroeniya chelovecheskikh yazykov i ego vliyanii na dukhovnoe razvitie chelovechestva” [On Language: On the Diversity of Human Language Construction and its Influence on the Mental Development of the Human Species], in: Humboldt V. von. Izbrannye trudy po yazykoznaniyu [Selected Works on Linguistics]. Moscow: Progress, 2000. (In Russian)
    21. 

  21. Ivanov, D.V. “Sud'ba metafiziki v analiticheskoi filosofii: Karnap, Kuain, Kripke” [The Faith of Metaphysics in Analytic Philosophy: Carnap, Quine, Kripke], Filosofskie nauki, 2009, no. 4, pp. 99‒113. (In Russian)
    22. 

  22. Jackendoff, R.S. Patterns in The Mind: Language and Human Nature. New York: Basic Books, 1994.
    23. 

  23. Kegl, J., A. Senghas & M. Coppola. “Creation Through Contact: Sign Language Emergence and Sign Language Change in Nicaragua”, in: M. De Graff (ed.). Language Creation and Language Change. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1999, pp. 179-237.
    24. 

  24. Kripke, S. “Naming and Necessity”, in: G. Harman & D. Davidson (eds.) The Semantics of Natural Language. Dordrecht: Springer, 1972, pp. 254‒355.
    25. 

  25. Levinson, S.C. Space in Language and Cognition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003.
    26. 

  26. Makeeva, L.B. Yazyk, ontologiya i realism [Language, Ontology, and Realism]. Moscow: VShE, 2011, 312 pp. (In Russian)
    27. 

  27. Nevins A., Pesetsky D., Rodriguez C. “Pirahã exceptionality: a reassessment”, Language, 2009, vol. 85, no. 2, pp. 355‒404.
    28. 

  28. Osborne, L. “A Linguistic Big Bang”, The New York Times, sect. 6:84, 1999, October 24.
    29. 

  29. Pinker, s. The Language Instinct: The New Science of Language and Mind. Vol. 7529. Penguin UK, 1995.
    30. 

  30. Putnam, H. “Meaning and Reference”, The Journal of Philosophy, 1973, vol. 70, no. 19, pp. 699‒711.
    31. 

  31. Quine, W.V. “Epistemology Naturalized”, in: Quine, W.V. Ontological Relativity and Other Essays. New York: Columbia University Press, 1969, pp. 69-90.
    32. 

  32. Quine, W.V. “Ontological Relativity”, in: Quine, W.V. Ontological Relativity and Other Essays. New York: Columbia University Press, 1969, pp. 26-68.
    33. 

  33. Quine, W.V. “Designation and Existence”, The Journal of Philosophy, 1939, no. 36, pp. 706‒707.
    34. 

  34. Quine, W. V. “Indeterminacy of Translation Again”, The Journal of Philosophy, 1987, vol. 84, no. 1, pp. 5‒10.
    35. 

  35. Quine, W.V. “Two Dogmas of Empiricism”, Philosophical Review, 1951, no. 60, pp. 20‒43.
    36. 

  36. Ranta, A. Type-Theoretical Grammar. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994, 226 pp.
    37. 

  37. Rogonyan, G.S. “Devidson ob istine, normakh i dispozitsiyakh” [Davidson on Truth, Norms, and Dispositions], Epistemology & Philosophy of Science, 2018, vol. 55, no. 4, pp. 68‒83. DOI: 10.5840/eps201855469
    38. 

  38. Rorty, R. Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1979.
    39. 

  39. Sacks, O. Seeing Voices: A Journey into the World of the Deaf. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989.
    40. 

  40. Sandler, W. & D. Lillo-Martin. Sign Language and Linguistic Universals. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006. 572 pp.
    41. 

  41. Schaller, S. A Man Without Words. York: Summit Books, 1991.
    42. 

  42. Vostrikova E.V., Kusliy P.S. “Grammatikalizatsiya kategorial'noi oshibki i estestvennyi yazyk” [Grammaticalization of Category Mistake and Natural Language], Voprosy Filosofii, 2020, in print. (In Russian)
    43. 

  43. Vostrikova E., Kusliy, P.S. “Tavtologii i protivorechiya v filosofii yazyka: kognitivnye i grammaticheskie aspekty” [Tautologies and Contradictions in Philosophy of Language: Cognitive and Grammatical Aspects], The Digital Scholar: Philosopher’s Lab, 2019, vol. 2, no. 4, pp. 82‒102.
    44. 

  44. Whorf, B.L. Language, Thought, and Reality. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1956.
    45. 

  45. Wittgenstein, L. Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1974.
    46.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate