Везде
REFORM OF RAS: EXPERT ANALYSIS. ARTICLE 1. REFORM OF RAS: PROJECT OF MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
REFORM OF RAS: EXPERT ANALYSIS. ARTICLE 1. REFORM OF RAS: PROJECT OF MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE
Annotation
PII
S086904990000617-0-1
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Victor Polterovich 
Edition
Issue 1
Pages
5-28
Abstract
The theory of reforms usually assumes that a designer aims to increase public welfare under existing constraints. In practice, however, initiators of reforms quite often proceed from false premises, and pursue political and-or self-interested goals. In this paper, we analyze an example of such an initiative – the project of reform of the Russian Academy of Science, offered by The Ministry of Education and Science in June 2013.
Keywords
reform design, costs of reform, civil society, fundamental research, catching up development, science and authorities
Date of publication
03.02.2014
Number of purchasers
1
Views
1078
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite   Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials

Balatskij E. Dissertatsionnaya lovushka // Svobodnaya mysl'-KhKhI. 2005. № 2.
 Bodyagina E. VTsIOM: Fursenko priznan samym nelyubimym ministrom // RBK daily. 13.07. 2011 (http://www.pda.rbcdaily.ru/politics/562949980630920).
 Bocharova S., Tuntsov A. Nedruzhelyubnye akademiki // Gazeta.ru. 2008. 25 maya (http://www. gazeta.ru/politics/2008/05/29_a_2739122.shtml).
 Varshavskij A.E. Problemy nauki: RAN i vuzy // Zhurnal Novoj ehkonomicheskoj assotsiatsii. 2010. № 8.
 Varshavskij A.E., Markusova V. Potracheno s umom. Rezul'tativnost' nauchnogo truda v Rossii vyshe, chem v Amerike // Poisk. 2009. № 21. 27 maya.
 Vedeneeva N. Prezident RAN Fortov: “My ne retrogrady, no ehtot dokument – uzhe ehkstremal'schina” // Moskovskij komsomolets. 2013. 29 iyunya.
 Georgiev G. Nauka bez byurokratii (S&TRFhttp://www.strf.ru/material.aspx?CatalogId=221&d_ no=56819).
 Ginzburg V. Akademiya nauk dolzhna byt' chast'yu grazhdanskogo obschestva // The New Times. 2006. № 29.
 Grinberg R.S. Ehkspertnaya otsenka institutom ehkonomiki RAN dostovernosti zatrat na reformirovanie RAN v zakonoproekte pravitel'stva RF (http://www.echo.msk.ru/blog/ grinberg_r/1122660-echo/).
 Gudkov L. Otnoshenie k pravovym institutam v Rossii // Monitoring obschestvennogo mneniya: ehkonomicheskie i sotsial'nye peremeny. 2000. № 3.
 Guriev S., Livanov D., Severinov K. Shest' mifov Akademii nauk // Ehkspert. 2009. № 48.
 Doklad glavnogo uchenogo sekretarya Prezidiuma RAN akademika V.V. Kostyuka “O rabote Prezidiuma RAN i vypolnenii reshenij Obschikh sobranij Rossijskoj akademii nauk v 2008– 2012 gg.”. Obschee sobranie Rossijskoj akademii nauk, 28 maya 2013 g. (http://www.ras.ru/news/ shownews.aspx?id=548d7ff1-b546-4a27-99c3-40ada28d68c2).
 Zayavlenie ehkonomistov-issledovatelej v svyazi s proverkami NKO na predmet soblyudeniya zakonodatel'stva ob “inostrannykh agentakh”, 2013 (http://www.arett.ru/ru/about/statement/).
 Itogi federal'nogo statisticheskogo nablyudeniya v sfere oplaty truda otdel'nykh rabotnikov za I kvartal 2013 g. (http://www.gks.ru/free_doc/new_site/PublishOTKR/index. html#table).
 Mazurova L. Potrebitel' nynche v defitsite // Literaturnaya gazeta. 2007. 8 avgusta.
 Markusova V.A. Bibliometricheskie pokazateli rossijskikh universitetov // Nauchnaya i innovatsionnaya politika. Rossiya i mir 2011–2012. Razdel 4.11. M., 2013.
 Machavariani G.I. Mesto RAN v rossijskoj nauke (http://www.imemo.ru/ru/publ/ comments/2013/comm_2013_017.pdf).
 Nauchnaya reforma na primere ITEhFa // Polit.ru. 8 iyulya 2013 g. (http://polit.ru/ article/2013/07/08/itep_reform/).
 Parshin A.N. (sostavitel'). Rossijskaya akademiya nauk. Khronika protesta. Iyun'–iyul' 2013 g. Izdanie vtoroe, dopolnennoe i ispravlennoe. M., 2013.
 Polterovich V.M. Missiya ehkonomicheskogo zhurnala i institut retsenzirovaniya // Zhurnal Novoj ehkonomicheskoj assotsiatsii. 2011. № 12.
 Polterovich V.M. Pochemu ne idut reformy. Neobkhodim gosudarstvennyj standart na ikh proektirovanie // Politicheskij zhurnal. 2005. № 13.
 Polterovich V.M. Sovety retsenzentu. 2010a. (http://www.econorus.org/sub.phtml?id=69).
 Polterovich V.M. Ehkonomicheskaya nauka v Rossii: izderzhki globalizatsii i reforma RAN // Zhurnal novoj ehkonomicheskoj assotsiatsii. 2010b. № 8.
 Polterovich V.M. Ehlementy teorii reform. M., 2007.
 Polterovich V.M., Popov V.V. Ehvolyutsionnaya teoriya ehkonomicheskoj politiki. Ch. I. Opyt bystrogo razvitiya // Voprosy ehkonomiki. 2006a. № 7.
 Polterovich V.M., Popov V.V. Ehvolyutsionnaya teoriya ehkonomicheskoj politiki. Ch. II.
 Neobkhodimost' svoevremennogo pereklyucheniya // Voprosy ehkonomiki. 2006b. № 8.
 Polterovich V.M., Fridman A.A. Ehkonomicheskaya nauka i ehkonomicheskoe obrazovanie v Rossii: problema integratsii // Ehkonomicheskaya nauka sovremennoj Rossii. 1998. № 2.
 Profsoyuz RAN trebuet otstavki Fursenko // Newsland. 2010. 14.05. (http://newsland.com/ news/detail/id/502412/).
 Reformy glazami amerikanskikh i rossijskikh uchenykh. M., 1996.
 Rogov S.M. Novaya shokovaya terapiya i “reforma RAN”: realii rossijskoj nauki. M., 2013.
 Rostovtsev A. ITEhF i ego svetloe buduschee. Troitskij variant. 2012. № 101. 10 aprelya (http://trv-science.ru/2012/04/10/itehf-i-ego-svetloe-budushhee/).
 Rostovtsev A. Nauka dlya svoikh // Gazeta.ru. 2013. 16 iyulya (http://www.gazeta.ru/ comments/2013/07/16_a_5431277.shtml).
 Sobolev V.N. Obraschenie k byvshemu glave Minobrnauki RF, nyne sovetniku Prezidenta RF A.A. Fursenko (http://www.za-nauku.ru/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=7334& Itemid=29).
 Sterligov I. Nauchnaya politika v tsifrakh (http://isterligov.blogspot.ca/2013/07/vs-wos. html).
 Taratuta Yu. Akademiki vyshli na byudzhetnuyu pryamuyu. Utverzhden novyj ustav RAN // Kommersant'. 2007b. 21 noyabrya.
 Taratuta Yu. Akademiki reformirovali Minobrnauki // Kommersant'. 2007a. 31 marta.
 Taratuta Yu. Akademicheskij rospusk. RAN mozhet prevratit'sya v klub uchenykh // Kommersant'. 2006. 23 iyunya.
 Taratuta Yu. Ministr ugovoril akademikov sokratit'sya // Kommersant'. 2004. 19 oktyabrya.
 Taratuta Yu. Svezhevyzhatyj srok // Kommersant'. 2008. 31 maya.
 Usov A. “Reforma” RAN – mest' za publichnoe unizhenie chlena kooperativa “Ozero” // Novyj Region 2. 2013. 28 iyunya (http://nr2.ru/science/446400.html).
 Chernykh A. Ehkzamen sdal. Andrej Fursenko ostavil podchinennym domashnee zadanie // Kommersant'. 2012. 20 fevralya.
 Aghion Ph. From Growth Theory To Growth Policy Design. LSE. Growth Comission. 2012.
 Burda M., Wyplosz C. Macroeconomics: a European Text. Oxford, 2009.
 Lin J.Y. New Structural Economics. A Framework for Rethinking Development and Policy. The World Bank. Washington (D.C.), 2011.
 The New Russia: Transition Gone Awry. Stanford, 2000.
 Rodrik D. Understanding Economic Policy Reform // Journal of Economic Literature. 1996. Vol.
 XXXIV.
 Stiglitz J. More Instruments and Broader Goals: Moving Toward the Post-Washington Consensus// Wider Annual Lectures 2, the United Nations University. May 1997.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate